Deep, Sleek And Bleak

Get ahead, go figure, go ahead and pull the trigger 
Everything under the gun

First thing first.  The Sisters Of Mercy are one of the most important bands of my musical life, they exploded into my consciousness when I was 17 and were all so deep, sleek and bleak they briefly warped me into being the only goth in south west Wales.  Floodland is very much an alltime Top 5 LP for me* and it still sounds perfectly poised and crystalline to my tired old ears.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 05 (2)

Second thing second.  I saw The Sisters at their tenth anniversary show at Leeds Polytechnic on 17 February 1991 and they were just incredible.  I was skinny, dressed all in black and hanging onto the rail at the front.  It is still very nearly my best gig ever.

Third thing third. To simplify matters a little, following a monumental strop/contractual ding-dong Andrew Eldritch** has not released any new music since 1993’s single Under The Gun, although new songs do feature in their live shows.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 06

Fourth thing fourth.  I was lured into seeing The Sisters Of Mercy on Saturday 7 march 2020 at Manchester Albert Hall by a couple of my mates.  I probably would not have bothered if left entirely to my own devices.

There’s your MF-ing context.


I have always loved a goth crowd and Saturday was no exception – I just like the way proper goths make such an effort and I have always had a thing for the women of the tribe^.  There were an amusing amount of us there that were obviously first editions, all apart from a few chosen ones, a damn sight less consumptive looking than we used to be and far less hairy^^.

The Albert Hall, Manchester is my very favourite venue in the north, a stunning looking ex-Methodist chapel, lots of beautiful tiles and glass; capacity of about 2000 but bigger bands love to play there.

Sisters Albert Hall Manchester 01
Before the flood (land)

With Germanic precision the gig kicked off at 8:15, a keyboard dude stands at the back, two long-haired guitarists with identical guitars bossing a Vision Thing-era rock look hit the stage, someone switches Doktor Avalanche on and on comes the dude we have all been waiting for, Mr Eldritch.  The opener is the incredible ‘Lucretia, My Reflection’ and it sounds a bit … underpowered, inaudible vocals.  Teething problems with the sound maybe.

No.  For the hour and twenty minutes The Sisters were on stage it became pretty clear, pretty fast that this was just a poor gig.  Eldritch really didn’t seem to have any voice left at all, the guitarists did all the heavy lifting for him, vocally and he was just a bit … unprepossessing.  I have no issue with anyone going bald and putting a few pounds on, I’m no hypocrite I hope, but he was just bad on Saturday; at his best he was a magnetic, slinky enigmatic frontman.

Sisters Albert Hall Manchester 03

So many of the tunes were ham-fistedly arranged too, they slaughtered ‘This Corrosion’, cut it down in cold blood and the delicate drive of ‘First And Last And Always’ never stood a chance.  ‘Alice‘ survived better than most, as did ‘Marian’ and along with the, excellently played, ‘Flood I’ and ‘Flood II’ was the highlight.

We all filed out feeling suitably gloomy and a bit ripped off.  It was more than that for me though, I’ve lived long enough to know that you really shouldn’t have idols, they let you down, but I just can’t help it, that’s the way I am wired.  I felt heartbroken, truly.


It has taken me three days to listen to The Sisters Of Mercy again.  I was nervous, I didn’t want my love for them to have been tainted by a deeply unsatisfactory show.  I cued up Floodland on my iPod with the all the relish of a very hairy man about to pull a large plaster off his scrotum, in public, on a very cold morning.  It was great, truly.  In fact the result sent me on a Sisters bender, which is how I end up here Under The Gun tonight.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 07

Released to promote a greatest hits-y thing true obsessive dweebs like me didn’t need Under The Gun had an interesting genesis.  Terri Nunn, ex-Berlin, had her, umm, breath taken away when she heard ‘This Corrosion’ on the radio and contacted Mr Eldritch with a song she wanted to record.  Bang, bang, bang, bash, bash, bash – guitars duly added, along with an incendiary rant from Eldritch and Under the Gun took flight.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 01Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 02

It really is a suitably odd record; half synth pop balladry and half demon dark.  It took me a while to like it, but it won me over and hasn’t lost anything in the 6 years, or so, since I last played it.  Terri Nunn’s vocals are great, all manner of yearning and depth in there, a rawness too but in a very AM radio stylee.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 03
From The Mighty Scrapbook of Rock

The track gets darker as it continues, moving from a late 80’s soundtrack sound to something really odd as the guitar makes itself known and after a 1-2-3-4 Eldritch launches into a great ranting monologue, mixed damn low in the mix; purposefully, to avoid some troubled hick with a litigious family blowing his head off to it in Buttfuck, Idaho (stolen from article shown below).

Forget the many steps to heaven
It never happened and it ain't so hard
Happiness is a loaded weapon and a
Short cut is better by far

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 08

The 12″ has two mixes – Metropolis and Jutland. The latter is a bit longer and the Eldritch bit is a little clearer, is my scientific analysis of that.  I prefer the Metropolis mix myself, it’s smoother, like me.  ‘Alice (1993)’ is a retooling of the 1983 track, it is a gleaming brighter, harder and more strident mix, good, but it loses the endearingly quirky charms of the original.


Anyone know how I can open this in a taller window so I could see The Nipples of Eldritch? just asking.


985 Down.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 05

PS: account I used of the song’s genesis, here.

Sisters of Mercy Under The Gun 04

*one of, at the last count, 10 Top 5 LP’s in fact.

**who is the Sisters of Mercy, they ceased to be a band in any real sense after First And Last And Always.

^which remains to date, entirely unreciprocated.

^^unless you count ears and noses.

22 thoughts on “Deep, Sleek And Bleak

  1. It may be some tiny consolation all these years after the fact that the Leeds date of that tour was almost exactly the same. Barely audible vocals, some dire arrangements, the keyboard player standing in an annoying crucifixion pose in every song… It sticks in my mind because it was the last gig I went to before lockdown!

    1. I’d forgotten about the annoying keyboard pose … I’m all worked up again now Tim!! Last gig for me too, it already felt a bit wrong being surrounded by so many people, even goths.

  2. Just love that gig photo showing the ceiling of the hall. You are really quite good at that snapping images stuff.
    Apropos of nothing, you are unlikely to recall an interview I did with Clifford Ennis (from Liverpool via Goldmine Records, Melbourne) re his ‘goth’ band Subterfuge. I think you and he have rather similar tastes; he often wears a Sisters t-shirt in the shop.

    1. Cheers Bruce. What my photo doesn’t show is just how much glass there is up there too, it’s a really beautiful building. Bands seem to love it as a venue.

  3. Truly sucks when a show breaks your heart like that. Well done for getting back on the horse though. I didn’t listen to AC/DC for a gazillion years after they let me down.

    Also, well done to Sisters Of Mercy for their superior pun resistance. I’d have definitely called this song Under The Nunn.

  4. I enjoyed your take way more than you enjoyed the show. I seen Lou Reed once and he was baked out of his mind. Not the best show i ever seen. I continued on and listened to Lou. I figured CB has messed up a few times and was given a chance to mess up again. Which I did with consistency.
    I made a note of ‘Floodland’

  5. I remember during the last US presidential election that Eldritch threatened to put out a new Sisters album should Trump manage to win. From the sounds of your review, it seems like it was a good thing that Eldritch didn’t follow through. A shame really. I truly loved these guys. Even back in 1999 when I last saw them live, they still had some oomph…

    1. Yeah, I think I remember reading that too. He did play about 5 new tracks, one of which was good ‘Show Me’.

      I was really bummed out by this one.

      1. I’m sure he’s got a few albums worth of new material. It seemed like he always had new tracks that he was writing whenever he went around on tour.

  6. Sorry to read that the gig let you down Joe. That one pic you posted that place looks awesome.
    Perhaps next time you should hang with the ‘women of the tribe’ as you would probably get your moneys worth.
    Some of these acts just don’t know when to knock it on the head and call it day.

    1. I know, I know, form an orderly queue here ladies!
      I’ve never been let down like that by an act I loved, I usually bail on them before they can. You had that happen to you?

      1. A band that I liked but did not love and that was Poison back in January 91.
        Dall the Bass Player lazed around by lying on a ramp for about half the show.
        Two solos that took up 20 minutes of a 90-minute show and a set list that had not really changed from the tour before except for 4 songs they played from there current tour at the time.
        The fact that it was a 9 hour drive to see them added insult. Had a good time though just not at that show!
        Never will I ever pay a ticket to see those guys again.

      2. Ha! Man oh man! Did you write that one up yet?
        If I drove 9 hours for a show I’d want to see Nirvana with John Bonham and Bon Scott guesting at the end of it! Fuck Unskinny Bop!!

      3. Well Joe you see where we live we had to travel to go and see these acts as they would not play here back in there heyday.
        Had no choice really. You get used to the distance.
        From Tbay to Winnipeg- 6-9 hours drive. Depending on Tbone and the speed at which he was punching the gas pedal.

        To Duluth Minnesota was 3 hours drive and to Minneapolis was about 6 hours.

        Like I said you get used to it. I would have missed a ton of shows for sure If I stayed and home haha

Leave a Reply to 1537Cancel reply